Wedding Bells & Baubles

Shop more: All Rings | Diamond Rings | Gemstone Rings | Bridal Pearls | Pearl Earrings

    Filter
      7 products
      Sold Out
      "My Fancy!" Sz 7 Ring - Amethyst, 18k Gold Sterling | Key West Local Luxe
      "My Fancy!" Sz 7 Ring - Amethyst, 18k Gold Sterling – view 2
      Outlet "My Fancy!" Sz 7 Ring - Amethyst, 18k Gold Sterling
      $ 329.00 $ 129.00 Save $ 200.00
      Sale
      "Beautiful Dream” Sz 6.5 Ring - Blue & White Diamonds, 18k White Gold | Key West Local Luxe
      "Beautiful Dream” Sz 6.5 Ring - Blue & White Diamonds, 18k White Gold – view 2
      "Beautiful Dream” Sz 6.5 Ring - Blue & White Diamonds, 18k White Gold
      $ 2,499.00 $ 2,199.00 Save $ 300.00
      Sale
      "Very Engaging!" Sz 7 Ring - Citrine, Zircon Stone, Anti-tarnish Sterling Silver | Key West Local Luxe
      "Very Engaging!" Sz 7 Ring - Citrine, Zircon Stone, Anti-tarnish Sterling Silver – view 2
      "Very Engaging!" Sz 7 Ring - Citrine, Zircon Stone, Anti-tarnish Sterling Silver
      $ 599.00 $ 289.00 Save $ 310.00
      Sale
      "Lovely Life" Size 7 Ring - Prasiolite, Diamonds, 14k Gold | Key West Local Luxe
      "Lovely Life" Size 7 Ring - Prasiolite, Diamonds, 14k Gold – view 2
      "Lovely Life" Size 7 Ring - Prasiolite, Diamonds, 14k Gold
      $ 2,489.00 $ 2,399.00 Save $ 90.00
      Sale
      "Crush” Sz 7 Ring Set - Rubellite Tourmaline,diamond 14k Gold | Key West Local Luxe
      "Crush” Sz 7 Ring Set - Rubellite Tourmaline,diamond 14k Gold – view 2
      "Crush” Sz 7 Ring Set - Rubellite Tourmaline,diamond 14k Gold
      $ 2,499.00 $ 2,249.00 Save $ 250.00
      Sale
      "You Read my Mind!" Sz 10 Ring - Garnet, Sterling | Key West Local Luxe
      "You Read my Mind!" Sz 10 Ring - Garnet, Sterling – view 2
      "You Read my Mind!" Sz 10 Ring - Garnet, Sterling
      $ 199.00 $ 159.00 Save $ 40.00
      Sale
      "Velvet Evening" Sz 8 Ring - Sapphire, Diamonds, Anti-tarnish Sterling, 18k Gold Accents | Key West Local Luxe
      "Velvet Evening" Sz 8 Ring - Sapphire, Diamonds, Anti-tarnish Sterling, 18k Gold Accents – view 2
      "Velvet Evening" Sz 8 Ring - Sapphire, Diamonds, Anti-tarnish Sterling, 18k Gold Accents
      $ 899.00 $ 649.00 Save $ 250.00

      Alternative Engagement Rings & Wedding Jewelry

      Not everybody wants the same diamond solitaire as everybody else. Our engagement and wedding rings feature sapphires, garnets, topaz, amethyst, and diamonds, all one-of-a-kind and set in sterling silver and gold. For the couple who wants a ring with a story, and maybe a Key West sunset in the background.

      Shop more: All Rings | Diamond Rings | Gemstone Rings | Bridal Pearls | Pearl Earrings

      Wedding & Engagement FAQ

      What is an alternative engagement ring?
      Any engagement ring that isn't a traditional white diamond solitaire. Think colored gemstones like sapphire, garnet, or topaz, unique settings, or mixed stones. They're more personal, often more affordable, and nobody else will have the same one.

      What if the ring isn't the right size?
      Most of our rings are one-of-a-kind and available in the size listed. Check the size in each title, and if you're shopping as a surprise, borrow a ring they already wear on that finger and have it measured at any local jeweler.

      Do you have jewelry for brides and bridesmaids?
      Yes! Pearls are a timeless bridal choice. Shop our Pearl collection and Pearl Earrings for the bride, and find bridesmaid gifts they'll actually wear again in Wonders Under $100.

      Getting married in Key West?
      Congratulations! Stop by our store on the island to see pieces in person, or shop online and we'll ship it to you. Just order early so it arrives well before the big day.