Best Sellers

Shop more: New Arrivals | Pearls | Sea Life & Larimar | Under $100 | Under $250

    Filter
      611 products
      Sale
      ?PEarl Bloom’ Ring - Pearl Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      ?PEarl Bloom’ Ring - Pearl Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      "Pearl Bloom" Ring - Pearl, Sterling
      $ 129.00 $ 78.00 Save $ 51.00
      Sale
      ?GOin’ for Baroque’ 1’’ Earrings - Baroque Pearl.925 Sterling Silver - Key West Local Luxe
      ?GOin’ for Baroque’ 1’’ Earrings - Baroque Pearl.925 Sterling Silver - Key West Local Luxe
      "Goin' for Baroque" 1" Earrings - Baroque Pearl, .925 Sterling Silver
      $ 389.00 $ 349.00 Save $ 40.00
      Sale
      ?KAsumi Style’ 8’’ Bracelet - Pearls Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      ?KAsumi Style’ 8’’ Bracelet - Pearls Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      "Kasumi Style" 8" Bracelet - Pearls, Sterling
      $ 299.00 $ 249.00 Save $ 50.00
      Sale
      ?DOuble Bubble’ Med-lg Hinged Cuff Bracelet - 13mm Edison Pearls Topaz Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      ?DOuble Bubble’ Med-lg Hinged Cuff Bracelet - 13mm Edison Pearls Topaz Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      "Double Bubble" Med-lg Hinged Cuff Bracelet - 13mm Edison Pearls, Topaz, Sterling
      $ 269.00 $ 199.00 Save $ 70.00
      Sale
      ?BEauty to Go’ Storage & Travel Pouch - Velvet - Key West Local Luxe
      ?BEauty to Go’ Storage & Travel Pouch - Velvet - Key West Local Luxe
      "Beauty to Go" Storage & Travel Pouch - Velvet
      $ 25.00 $ 18.00 Save $ 7.00
      Sale
      ?MY Cup Runneth Over’ 7’’ - 8’’ Bracelet - Pearls Anti-tarnish Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      ?MY Cup Runneth Over’ 7’’ - 8’’ Bracelet - Pearls Anti-tarnish Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      "My Cup Runneth Over" 7" - 8" Bracelet - Pearls, Anti-tarnish Sterling
      $ 99.00 $ 78.00 Save $ 21.00
      Sale
      ?TOurmaline Treasure Gem Strand’ 16’’ to 18’’ Necklace - Tourmaline Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      ?TOurmaline Treasure Gem Strand’ 16’’ to 18’’ Necklace - Tourmaline Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      "Tourmaline Treasure Gem Strand" 16" to 18" Necklace - Tourmaline, Sterling
      $ 139.00 $ 119.00 Save $ 20.00
      Sale
      ?SHelly-shell Hoops!’ 3’’ Earrings - Shells Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      ?SHelly-shell Hoops!’ 3’’ Earrings - Shells Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      "Shelly-shell Hoops!" 3" Earrings - Shells, Sterling
      $ 94.00 $ 89.00 Save $ 5.00
      Sale
      ?BOticelli’s Dream’ Rings - Pearls Topaz Sterling Bronze Accents - Ring Key West Local Luxe
      ?BOticelli’s Dream’ Rings - Pearls Topaz Sterling Bronze Accents - Ring Key West Local Luxe
      "Boticelli's Dream" Rings - Pearls, Topaz, Sterling, Bronze Accents
      $ 379.00 $ 299.00 Save $ 80.00
      Sale
      ?TEmptations’ 7’’ to 9’’ Bracelet - Labradorite Pearl - Key West Local Luxe
      ?TEmptations’ 7’’ to 9’’ Bracelet - Labradorite Pearl - Key West Local Luxe
      "Temptations" 7" to 9" Bracelet - Labradorite, Pearl
      $ 119.00 $ 78.00 Save $ 41.00
      Sale
      ?MY Octopus Pearl’ Pendant Necklace - Mabé Pearl Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      ?MY Octopus Pearl’ Pendant Necklace - Mabé Pearl Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      "My Octopus Pearl" Pendant Necklace - Mabé Pearl, Sterling
      $ 299.00 $ 254.15 Save $ 44.85
      Sale
      Outlet: ?Girl Power!’ 1’’ Figa Pendant Charm - Coral 14k Gold - Key West Local Luxe
      Outlet: ?Girl Power!’ 1’’ Figa Pendant Charm - Coral 14k Gold - Key West Local Luxe
      Outlet: "Girl Power!" 1" Figa Pendant Charm - Coral, 14k Gold
      $ 405.00 $ 199.00 Save $ 206.00
      Sale
      ?LA Concha’ 1’’ Earrings - Larimar Topaz Anti-tarnish Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      ?LA Concha’ 1’’ Earrings - Larimar Topaz Anti-tarnish Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      "La Concha" 1" Earrings - Larimar, Topaz, Anti-tarnish Sterling
      $ 169.00 $ 129.00 Save $ 40.00
      Sale
      ?EMerald Studs’ - Emerald.925 Sterling - Earrings Key West Local Luxe
      ?EMerald Studs’ - Emerald.925 Sterling - Earrings Key West Local Luxe
      "Emerald Studs" - Emerald, .925 Sterling
      $ 199.00 $ 149.00 Save $ 50.00
      Sale
      ?TIara’ (choose your Size) Ring - Moonstone & Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      ?TIara’ (choose your Size) Ring - Moonstone & Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      "Tiara" (choose your Size) Ring - Moonstone & Sterling
      $ 129.00 $ 89.00 Save $ 40.00
      Sale
      ?THe Classic’ 18’’ Pendant Necklace - Pearl Anti-tarnish Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      ?THe Classic’ 18’’ Pendant Necklace - Pearl Anti-tarnish Sterling - Key West Local Luxe
      "The Classic" 18" Pendant Necklace - Pearl, Anti-tarnish Sterling
      $ 89.00 $ 75.65 Save $ 13.35

      Our Best-Selling Jewelry

      These are the pieces everybody's talking about, and buying. Our most-loved pearls, Larimar, gemstones, and sea life designs, ranked by what our customers actually take home. If you're not sure where to start, start here.

      Shop more: New Arrivals | Pearls | Sea Life & Larimar | Under $100 | Under $250

      Best Sellers FAQ

      How are best sellers chosen?
      This page updates automatically based on what sells most, so it's always current. Only pieces that are in stock are shown.

      Will a best seller come back if it sells out?
      Sometimes, but many of our pieces are one-of-a-kind or made in small batches. If you love it, don't wait. Join our VIP Club to hear about new arrivals and restocks first.

      Do best sellers make good gifts?
      They're the safest bet in the store. If lots of people love it, chances are your person will too.